4

1

When I post a new question on Merspi, how can I go about writing a good title for my question?

What constitutes a good title? What isn't an example of a good title to use for posting a question?

flag

3 Answers

4

No sneak peek titles

The following titles are not very useful on the question list page.

  • When receiving offers...
  • A question about Kanji

You could improve the titles to something like:

  • Do I need to be in Australia when I receive my offer?
  • How much Kanji do I need to know?

Maintain punctuation and grammar. Avoid "personal" tone.

Avoid titles like this:

  • need someone's help with swot. i dont get it

Try something like this instead (notice how I have removed 'personal' words like someone and I):

  • What is SWOT analysis?

Use tags wherever possible

A good question title should focus on the question, rather than providing the subject or context.

Bad examples:

  • Maths Methods question
  • Momentum

Subject and contexts are for the tags instead: methods and momentum. The title is for the question.

A good question avoids these terms:

  • How do I maximise the area of rectangular fencing?
  • Finding the resulting velocity of a truck from a collision

Other users can simply add irrelevant subjects to Ignored Tags on their sidebar (on the main page of Merspi), and they can easily ignore those questions, so there's no need to provide that information in the title!

link|flag
Good point, it took me a while to remember I don't need to state the subject in the question because Tags do it for me. – asa.hoshi Jan 4 at 22:55
5

A Good Title

A good title is one that is specific to the topic/question and descriptive as possible.

Here a few examples of good titles:

  • Do we need to assign a direction to the spring constant?
  • Is there any way I get hard copies of VCE study designs for free?
  • Exam papers in a new study design for Physics
  • What's the most useful tip you could offer to a VCE student?
  • What’s the best way to get your ENTER score?

A Not-So-Great Title

  • 4.0 mA : is this 0.004A? (This title isn't very descriptive)
  • Bond Angles: VCE Chemistry (This title is likely to be repeated for all questions related to Bond Angles for Chemistry. It's not specific enough - ask yourself: what is it specifically about bond angles you are asking?)
  • In math methods 3/4, how can I differentiate this? (As a general rule, subject titles should be included as tags - math and methods and don't need to be included in the title.)

A good question to ask yourself is: how can I help others to find my question? The questions with the best titles are typically found by Google. If you have a question, chances are someone else might have the same question at a later date - do them a favour!

Please remember all these are just suggestions and guidelines for the Merspi community. Merspi believes in empowering the users and community of Merspi to take it upon themselves where-ever possible to work out the best way to behave as a community.

That's why users are able to edit each others questions. If you think a question or answer can be improved, be brave - go for it!

Merspi is about working as a team. You Are Merspi!

link|flag
Bond angles are such a small part of the course that I think that title is good, but I get what you are trying to say! If it was "Differentiation: Maths Methods", it'd be pointless – Collin Li Jan 4 at 22:28
Bond angles may have been a bad example! (My lack of knowledge surrounding Chemistry is showing itself :-)) – James Spittal Jan 13 at 8:31
2

For simple questions I prefer to see a straightforward title as question (with explanation/question within if applicable)

For instance: Is it worth getting a tutor for VCE English?


For the more complex or 'long-winded' questions I personally prefer to see a simple title with a few keywords (to determine if I know anything on the topic)

For example: Tips on making a physics cheat sheet

An example of a poor title could be "It makes no sense" or "Can you help me?"

link|flag
Agree - the question title should be as informative as possible! – Collin Li Jan 13 at 7:34
Great point n.f May I also add, people should also write their question as a question so that the users of Merspi would click to see the "answer" or answer it themselves. If a user was to see a "statement" and not a "question" i.e. with a "?" why would they click it? It isn't ASKING anything. Hope that makes sense. – asa.hoshi Feb 1 at 14:56

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.